Handcrafted sundaes built with locally sourced ingredients, house-made syrups, and a whole lot of heart — right here in the heart of Hayward.
Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte started as a dream between two friends who believed that the best moments in life are the ones shared over a beautifully crafted dessert. What began as weekend pop-ups along the Hayward streets grew into something far more special — a cozy corner where neighbors become friends and every sundae is a small work of art.
We source our dairy from local farms, craft our syrups in-house every morning, and hand-pick our seasonal fruits from Wisconsin markets. Nothing is rushed. Nothing is ordinary. Just honest, heartfelt food made the way it should be — with care.
Every ingredient tells a local story
Handcrafted in small batches daily
From towering classic sundaes to our house-made coffee creations, every item on our menu is designed to make you pause, smile, and savor the moment.
Three scoops of vanilla bean ice cream topped with house-made cherry compote, whipped cream, and our famous warm fudge drizzle.
Caramel-swirled ice cream with our buttery house-made caramel sauce, Maldon sea salt, and a crunchy pretzel crumble topping.
A refreshing blend of strawberry and blueberry ice cream crowned with fresh Wisconsin berries, lavender honey drizzle, and edible flowers.
Our signature espresso blend meets velvety steamed milk and a touch of Belgian chocolate. Finished with cocoa powder dusting.
A soothing espresso drink infused with house-made lavender syrup and topped with a cloud of vanilla-infused oat milk foam.
Pick your base, choose your scoops, and explore our topping bar with over 50 options — from artisanal sprinkles to fresh fruit.
Can't decide? Ask about our Chef's Special — a new creation rotating every week.
Ask us about today's specialStep inside and you'll find warm lighting, the rich aroma of freshly brewed coffee, and the gentle hum of conversation. Our space is designed to feel like a living room you're always welcome in — whether you're celebrating a small victory or just need a sweet break in your day.
Host birthday parties, book club nights, or after-school hangouts. We love hosting the moments that make Hayward feel like home.
Our Build-Your-Own Sundae Bar is a hit with kids of all ages. We have a dedicated kids' menu and plenty of high chairs on hand.
We offer sundae catering for events of all sizes — from corporate gatherings to backyard celebrations. Let us bring the sweetness to you.
We're right in the heart of Hayward — easy to find, impossible to forget.
10555 Main
Hayward, WI 54843-6658
Have a question, want to book an event, or just want to say hi? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you sooner than you can say "extra sprinkles."
Thanks for reaching out — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.
